ïPrev

Network Learning/Solution #033

Nextð

 Use Menu Bar (click if not visible) for Teched Menu and ASWS site navigation

Corresponding and possibly equivalent or interchangeable standard references - updated 2004-08-18

Reference Standards:  TC67 guidance for selecting appropriate reference standards is given in TC67 N435 subclause 4.4 and the issue of dual references is further addressed in Annex I. 

It is frequently asked what standards are "equivalent"; what ISO/IEC Standards should be referenced in place of national or industry standards, and for "dual" referencing.  TC67 and ISO CS have prepared a  list of "equivalent" standards, Version.4, August 2004 (Excel spreadsheet) for guidance, that should be used with caution because exact equivalence is not always the case.  In some cases, the content between the covers (after the Foreword and any "special notes" etc.) is identical and is therefore equivalent in its entirety, in some cases the standards are equivalent for the purposes of making the reference, in some cases they are different but interchangeable, and in some cases one may incorporate another by normative reference in which case only the one is necessary.

It is the responsibility of the user to ensure that the "equivalence" or interchangeability is determined for each particular case, and that the latest editions of standards are considered.  TC67 and ISO CS would welcome any feedback to assist in maintaining this list.

It should also be noted that the "dual references" guidance is not based around the standards themselves being "identical", but on the equivalence of the specific provisions relevant to the reference being made.

Teched Information
& Links HOMEPAGE

Network Learnings

This page is a part of teched within ASWS and is maintained with the TC67 Portal by please type this address into your Email address box 
This page 'netlearning/learn033.htm' was last updated on 02 September 2004.